College football rankings, the BCS, and determining who will play for a national title are a lot like the health care debate. Everyone (ok, almost everyone) agrees something needs to be done, but what, and how? My friends, I bring you The Ultimate College Football Solution.
1 – Get rid of the polls as they exist today. No voting. Your ranking should be determined by your win percentage.
2 – Eliminate non-conference games. I’m looking at you Penn State and Florida. This of course generates a new problem since not all conferences have the same amount of teams. Or does it? The smallest conference basically would set the amount of regular season games played in a season. For example, Wisconsin would have to play ten games to get through the entire Big Ten conference whereas another school might only have to play eight games. The season then becomes eight games long for everyone, which is actually fine since right now Wisconsin doesn’t end up playing everyone in a season anyway. This would shorten the regular season and leave plenty of room for some playoffs. For those who will whine about only eight games, hey, if your team is worth watching they should make the playoffs. All of the second place conference teams can square off in an NIT bowl tournament if they want to. Non-conference games could stick around, too, but only if they’re played on a system where everyone plays everyone and schools don’t get to pick their opponents.
3 – The winners of every conference get to square off in a battle royale of NCAA Fall Madness.
4 – Self evident, but no more BCS!